Best Cat Birthday Cake Recipes!

Reviewed By Tom •  Updated: 01/04/24 •  11 min read
The contents of the website, such as text, graphics, images, and other material contained on this site (“Content”) are for informational purposes only. The Content is not intended to be a substitute for professional veterinarian advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always seek the advice of your veterinarian with any questions you may have regarding the medical condition of your pet. Never disregard professional advice or delay in seeking it because of something you have read on this website! Some of the links in this post are affiliate links. This means if you click on the link and purchase this item or service, we will receive an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. All opinions remain our own.

Does your precious kitty have a birthday coming up and you’d like to celebrate? Then consider making her a special birthday cake just for her! We’ll take a look at some cat-safe ingredients and recipes you can use to create a birthday delicacy for the special kitty in your life!

Online Veterinary 24/7
Chat With A Veterinarian Online

Connect with a verified veterinarian in minutes. Licensed vets are available 24/7 to answer your questions. No need to worry about your furry family member.

Cat Birthday Cake Ideas

You’ll want to consider some cat-safe ingredients for your feline friend’s birthday cake! We’ve done the research and have some up with some ingredient suggestions for you.

1. Salmon: this excellent source of protein and omega 3s is something your cat’s sure to love. Now, humans don’t consider this a typical birthday cake ingredient, but we’re here to tell you that your fur baby will just looooovvve you if her cake includes salmon!

2. Eggs: cats enjoy eggs, just like their humans. In fact, eggs contain healthy protein and B vitamins that cats need. Eggs are safe for your kitty as long as they’re cooked or baked into a recipe. Never give her raw eggs, as she could develop food poisoning. Not something you want to happen when you make a homemade treat for your kitty’s birthday!

3. Chicken: again, this isn’t a typical birthday cake ingredient for humans, but cats will love it! Chicken is a healthy lean protein for cats and can make a tasty addition to your cat’s birthday cake recipe.

4. Bananas: are an excellent source of potassium and soluble fiber and is a great option to use a binding substance in a cake made for your cat!

5. Pumpkin: you may be surprised to learn that pumpkin’s healthy for cats and they love it! This low calorie snack is high in fiber and is another ingredient you can use as a binder in your kitty’s birthday cake recipe.

6. Cheese: we usually think of this as a food more suited to mice, but cats enjoy cheese, too. Healthy cheeses for cats include cheddar, Swiss and Gouda, which are high in calcium and protein and taste great when added to kitty treats.

These are a few of the cat-safe ingredients you can choose to create a lovely birthday cake for your fur baby!

What Ingredients Are Harmful to Cats?

Not all ingredients are safe for cats, so it’s essential to avoid using any ingredient that could make your kitty sick, including the following:

Dairy: it’s best to avoid dairy in your fur baby’s birthday cake. Not many pet parents know this, but many cats are lactose intolerant. Even a little bit of dairy can make these kitties sick.

Chocolate: while a chocolate cake is a favorite with pet parents, this kind of cake is toxic for your cat (and dog). Chocolate can cause vomiting, seizures, tremors, diarrhea, and more.

Alcohol: you may want to enjoy alcohol on your cat’s birthday; however, don’t give an alcoholic beverage to your cat. Alcohol and other ingredients are toxic to kitties.

Coffee: contains many of the same substances found in chocolate. So, you can count on coffee being toxic to your fur baby.

Uncooked bread dough: you may be tempted to use yeast in your cat’s cake, and that’s OK. But never give your fur baby uncooked bread dough or cake better that contains yeast. The yeast can build up in her system, causing bloating and other health issues.

Raw eggs: as noted above, cooked eggs are pretty safe for your cat’s birthday cake; however, raw eggs can contain salmonella and other bacteria that could make her sick. So, don’t allow your fur baby to have raw eggs.

You now know what ingredients to avoid in your kitty’s birthday cake. That means you’re ready to move on to our yummy cat birthday cake recipes! We hope your fur baby has a wonderful birthday and that she enjoys her cake!

Homemade Cat Birthday Cake Recipes

Now, let’s take a look at some homemade cat birthday cake recipes your fur baby’s sure to love! These recipes use ingredients you can easily find at your local grocery store, and we’ve even included a gluten-free recipe for kitties who need to avoid wheat and gluten. One note—as you’re preparing your cat’s birthday cake, we’re sure she will come running when she smells the ingredients! But be sure to make her wait until the cake’s ready, so she can enjoy the full effect of all these yummy ingredients!

Easy Cat Birthday Cake Recipe

This recipe is quick and easy to prepare. Here’s what you’ll need:


Makes two kitty cakes


1. Preheat the oven to 350° F (180° C). Begin with ½ can of tuna.

2. Measure 1 ½ tablespoons of all-purpose flour.

3. Take a pinch (about 1 teaspoon) of shredded cheese.

4. Crack the egg and separate out the egg white only.

5. Mix all ingredients together in a small bowl.

6. Using a muffin tin, apply cooking spray to two muffin cups (in the baking tin, near the center).

7. Fill the muffin tin with the first cake mixture, then follow steps 1-6 again for the second cake. Once you’ve filled the second muffin cup, then place the muffin tin in the oven.

8. Bake for 15 minutes.

9. While you wait, rinse off the cooked piece of shrimp and remove the tail.

10. Once the cakes are done, remove them from the oven and place on a plate or wire rack to completely cool.

11. If desired, the top of each cake with a piece of shrimp.

12. Serve to your fur baby and watch her enjoy!

Easy Cat Birthday Cake #2

Here’s another kitty birthday cake recipe you can make at home and then watch your cat devour!



1. In a medium mixing bowl, beat the eggs with the olive oil and fish. In addition, preheat the oven to 180 °C (350°F), with heat on the top and bottom of the oven.

2. Drain cans of tuna and mix the fish with the previous mixture.

3. Now, add the catnip and keep beating.

4. Sift the flour with the baking soda and add it in the dough, until smoothed and well-combined.

5. Grease a mold with oil, pour the dough into the mold and bake the kitty cake for 30-45 minutes.

6. When it is ready, remove the cake from the oven, let it cool, take it out of the mold and watch your precious fur baby devour her cake without a second thought! She will love you for this yummy kitty creation!

Meat Cat Birthday Cakes

All cats love meat and will be puuurrrrfectly happy with a cat birthday cake made from meat!



1. Preheat oven to 350°F (180°C); be sure the heat is turned on for the top and the bottom, to make sure the cakes cook evenly.

2. In a medium mixing bowl, beat the eggs with the oil.

3. Next, add the meat and the carrot, then keep mixing until everything is well combined.

4. Add in the flour and baking soda, again until everything is well combined and the mixture is smooth.

5. Pour the cake batter/dough into a greased mold and bake for 30-45 minutes.

6.  Remove the cake(s) from the oven, and then let completely cool. Then stand back as your kitty happily chows down on this wonderful cat birthday cake!

Gluten Free Cat Birthday Cake Recipe

Here’s a gluten free option if your cat is on a grain-free or gluten free diet! She’s going to love the flavor of this special birthday cake!



1. In a large mixing bowl, mix tuna, chicken and sweet potato until the dough firmly holds together.

2. Next, take about 3 tablespoons of the mixture and use this to create a patty. Just use your hands to press the patty into shape or use a mold or even a cookie cutter to shape the kitty cake.

3. Then you’ll need to place some mashed potato into a plastic bag, with the corner cut off. Using the bag as a design tool, create flowers, fish and other fun shapes on your cat’s cake.

4. Next, you can put some other kitty-safe treats on top of the cake and then serve it all to your cat. Watch her dig in—she’ll have half the cake already eaten before you can make it to the end of the Happy Birthday song!

Cakes for Cats with Icing

Now, we realize your cat probably won’t care if the cake you make for her has frosting on it or not. When it comes to frosting on a birthday cake, it’s usually the pet parents who want the cake to include frosting. After all, what kind of cake for a birthday doesn’t include frosting, even for a kitty’s birthday!

Frosting ideas include:

Cat Birthday Treats

What about some other type of cat treats for your feline friend’s birthday? We’ve got you covered!

Blue Buffalo Wilderness Soft-Moist Grain-Free Cat Treats Variety Pack-4 Flavors: give your kitty a variety pack of treats for her birthday! She’s sure to enjoy these: chicken & duck; chicken & trout; chicken & salmon, and chicken & turkey treats! They’re made with real meat and contain no artificial preservatives, colors or flavors. These treats are also free of by-product meals and contain no corn, soy or wheat. Each pouch is about 2 oz.

Wellness Kittles Cat Treat Variety Pack-3 Flavors: here’s another treat your cat’s sure to love for her birthday! This package comes with 3 flavors: chicken & cranberries; salmon & cranberries; and tuna & cranberries. These treats are made with 100% natural ingredients and make a yummy crunchy treat for adult cats. They’re made with natural ingredients and contain nothing artificial. Plus, they’re low-calorie, making them a great treat for cats who need to lose a little weight.

Friskies Party Mix Cat Treats: this cat treat is an excellent choice for cats who love cheese! These cheesy treats are made with real cheese—a blend of Cheddar, Swiss and Monterey Jack. Just the taste your cat is sure to love! She’ll also enjoy the crunchy texture, which also helps to keep her teeth clean. What a great treat for your cat’s birthday!

Birthday Cake for Cats Near Me

If you’re not one of those who enjoys spending time in the kitchen, or you just don’t have time but would like to have some special for your kitty’s birthday, then we can help! These days, if you live in a larger city or metropolitan area, then you may have seen bakeries and shops that create yummy treats for dogs and cats! To find a cat bakery near you, just do a quick Google search. Type this phrase into Google’s search bar “cat birthday cake near me,” and Google will quickly (almost at the speed of light!) bring up a list of places where you can order a special surprise for your kitty’s birthday! It’s just that simple!

We hope this kitty birthday cake guide has provided you with some creative ideas to help give your cat the best birthday ever! And we’d like to wish you both all the best and much fun as you celebrate!

(Visited 9,139 times, 1 visits today)
Online Veterinary 24/7
Chat With A Veterinarian Online

Connect with a verified veterinarian in minutes. Licensed vets are available 24/7 to answer your questions. No need to worry about your furry family member.


Tom has always loved to write since he was little - he wanted to be either a writer or a veterinary doctor, but he ended up being a professional writer while most of his works are based on animals. He was born in San Francisco but later moved to Texas to continue his job as a writer. He graduated from the University of San Francisco where he studied biotechnology. He is happily married and a soon to be father!

Keep Reading